From my collection.
Bought in Autumn 2016.
First listen: 8-11-2016.
Second listen: 8-3-2017.
Recording dates: December 2013 & February 2014.
Recording venue: Köln Philharmonie, Germany.
Recording engineer: Mark Hohn.
Running time: 64:40.
Classical relevance: Recommended with some caution.
Symphony in C minor.
Piano concerto in A minor.
Herbert Schuch, Piano.
WDR Sinfonieorchester Köln, Eivind Aadland.
Two warhorses of this composer, of which the piano concerto is heard to distraction. One of the pieces I have a hard time to listen to, mainly because the work is treated as a sort of bombastic Brahms concerto, and never seen as a work written by Grieg. So although the music is still valid as a fine composition, conductor and soloists most of the time fall down the pitfalls and play it in a totally distorted way. The soloist hammering away with all his might, the conductor helping him by pounding statements underlining the bombastic nature and both rob the work of all gentility. That happens also on this recording, albeit there are poetic moments in which Schuch avoids the traps set for him, but not enough the save the work as a whole. Still I prefer this recording to many I heard before. In this instance I quite like the recording.
The Symphony in C minor is treated as an undernourished child, as if the first and the last attempt to write a symphony is not worth your attention. It is one of the better takes, but I think the lightness of the first movement, is underplayed by the literal acceptance of the "Allegro molto moderato" which is far to molto in this case. Also the secondary melody lines are treated in the same way. The "Adagio"is way to slow, and turns almost into a lament. The third movement fares better but overall this is also a case of negligent behavior, and the acceptance of previous interpretations as valid. Aadland did not have a mind of his own in this respect. A pity, it would have made this otherwise remarkable series of recordings exceptional. As it is I deem this recording good, ( a bit diffused) but mediocre in the interpretation. Another thing that irritates me about the series as a complete set is the fact that every recording is different, but all have their flaws. It ranges from state of the art with some problems, to merely good. It is all recorded in the same venue, so I am flabbergasted why an engineer like Mark Hohn, could not find the ideal spot and keep to the settings. even during recording sessions there is manipulation of the sound as a whole. Down points for that too. But not to be too negative, most of the stuff I hear is expertly done, better as in many other cases on different labels. So as such I am quite happy with them. But when there is cause to grief I must be allowed to utter, and this is what I do.
Wednesday, March 8, 2017
From my collection. Date of purchase: January 2018. First listen: 6-2-2018. Second rerun: 24-2-2018. Label: Arion. Recording dates: Jun...
A fine disc. This is my second rerun, and I stick to my first review, which was quite a positive one. First review of this disc. ...
From the 206 titles available in the BIS sale, there were not many of interest for me. A lot of new composers, but their modernity was a tad...
Merula, Tarquinio. (c.1595-1665) Madrigali e Altre Musiche Concertate... (Madrigals & instrumental Works)New acquisition. Date of purchase: January 2018. First listen: 6-2-2018. Label: Pierre Verany. Recording dates: September 2000. Venue: ...
Eberl, Anton. (1765-1807) Concerto for 2 pianos and Orchestra opus 45, and Sonatas for four hands, opus 7, No. 1 & 2.New acquisition. Free gift from JPC de. Date of purchase: 6-2-2018 First listen. Recording dates: March 2008 & November 2011. Venue:...
Castello,. Dario. (before 1600-1644) Sonate Concertate in Stile Moderno 1629. (Sonatas Nr. 3-5, 7,9-17 from the second book.)New acquisition. Date of purchase: February 2018. First listen: 12-2-2018. Label: CPO. Recording dates: October 2013. Venue: Dorfkirche...
New acquisition. Date of purchase: January 2018. First listen: 8-2-2018. Label: Arion. Recording dates: October/ November 2002. Venue: ...
Renaissance- Organ music played on a newly build organ after Arp Schnitger in the Lutherse kerk in Groningen, The Netherlands. Top recommendation.New acquisition. Date of purchase: February 2018. First listen: 16-2-2018. (Twice) Label: Not given, Recording dates: September 2017...
New acquisition. Date of purchase: 2017. First listen: 19-2-2018. Label: Ricercar. Recording dates: May 1996. Venue: Blasii Kirche in Z...
The Heritage of Claudio Monteverdi, Castello, Dario. (?1621-?1658) CD 4 In Stil Moderno. Second rerun.New acquisition. Date of purchase: October 2017. First listen: 15-12-2017. Second rerun: 23-2-2018. Label: Ricercar. CD 4 from 7. Reco...
New acquisition. Purchase date: 2017. First listen: 29-1-2018. Label: Ondine. Recording dates are not mentioned. Venue: Tampere Hall an...