From my collection
Bought in March 2010.
First listen: 22-3-2010.
Second listen: 15-12-2010.
Third listen: 28-11-2016.
Recording dates: June 2004.
Recording venue: Grand Hall of Moscow, Russia.
Recording engineers: Maria Soboleva & Igor Veprintsev.
Running time: 63:48.
Classical relevance: Music you must first sample before buying.
Works performed by:
Russian State SO, Valeri Polyansky.
Far be it from me to say that the orchestral music from Taneyev is second rate, but neither can I say that it is top rate music. I keep having difficulty with his erratic way of composing. For me it sounds after a composer that tries to find a certain balance but gets there rarely. Moments of exaltation are there, but often is sounds like run of the mill music, with strange harmonies, and funny twists of a phrase. I must say first that the performance is very good. Polyansky keeps the adrenaline flowing by adopting swift tempi, and utilizing all details to emerge on the foreground. The recording sounds perfectly in the louder passages, but the softer parts are a bit lifeless and miss the punch. That's a acoustical problem.
The first Symphony has not many moments of distinction. The second movement reminds me strongly of Tchaikovsky, and here and there some others pop up, but essentially this work is a bit faceless.
The Third Symphony is much better conceived and has an unity that is missing in the first. The balance and structural coherence is apparent already in the first movement. The shaping of melodies that leave some kind of an impression is clearly formed by a tighter control of the orchestral possibilities. I like the second and third movement best, but as the first this work leaves me dissatisfied as a whole.
Tuesday, November 29, 2016
From my collection. Date of purchase: January 2018. First listen: 6-2-2018. Second rerun: 24-2-2018. Label: Arion. Recording dates: Jun...
A fine disc. This is my second rerun, and I stick to my first review, which was quite a positive one. First review of this disc. ...
From the 206 titles available in the BIS sale, there were not many of interest for me. A lot of new composers, but their modernity was a tad...
Merula, Tarquinio. (c.1595-1665) Madrigali e Altre Musiche Concertate... (Madrigals & instrumental Works)New acquisition. Date of purchase: January 2018. First listen: 6-2-2018. Label: Pierre Verany. Recording dates: September 2000. Venue: ...
Eberl, Anton. (1765-1807) Concerto for 2 pianos and Orchestra opus 45, and Sonatas for four hands, opus 7, No. 1 & 2.New acquisition. Free gift from JPC de. Date of purchase: 6-2-2018 First listen. Recording dates: March 2008 & November 2011. Venue:...
Castello,. Dario. (before 1600-1644) Sonate Concertate in Stile Moderno 1629. (Sonatas Nr. 3-5, 7,9-17 from the second book.)New acquisition. Date of purchase: February 2018. First listen: 12-2-2018. Label: CPO. Recording dates: October 2013. Venue: Dorfkirche...
New acquisition. Date of purchase: January 2018. First listen: 8-2-2018. Label: Arion. Recording dates: October/ November 2002. Venue: ...
Renaissance- Organ music played on a newly build organ after Arp Schnitger in the Lutherse kerk in Groningen, The Netherlands. Top recommendation.New acquisition. Date of purchase: February 2018. First listen: 16-2-2018. (Twice) Label: Not given, Recording dates: September 2017...
New acquisition. Date of purchase: 2017. First listen: 19-2-2018. Label: Ricercar. Recording dates: May 1996. Venue: Blasii Kirche in Z...
The Heritage of Claudio Monteverdi, Castello, Dario. (?1621-?1658) CD 4 In Stil Moderno. Second rerun.New acquisition. Date of purchase: October 2017. First listen: 15-12-2017. Second rerun: 23-2-2018. Label: Ricercar. CD 4 from 7. Reco...
New acquisition. Purchase date: 2017. First listen: 29-1-2018. Label: Ondine. Recording dates are not mentioned. Venue: Tampere Hall an...