From my collection.
Bought in January 2010.
Listening dates: 10-3-2010/5-4-2012/5-11-2016.
Label: BIS.
Recording dates: December 1986. ( Symphonies)
Recording venue: Stockholm Concert Hall, Sweden.
Recording engineer: Siegbert Ernst. (Symphonies)
Recording dates Violin Concerto: August 1994.
Recording venue: Malmö Concert Hall, Sweden.
Recording engineer: Robert von Bahr.
Running time: 78:31.
Classical relevance: Interesting, but nothing more than that.
Works performed:
See heading.
Works performed by:
Symphonies:
Stockholm Sinfonietta, Neeme Järvi.
Roland Pöntinen, Piano/Symphony No. 5.
Violin concerto:
Anton Kontra, Violin.
Malmö SO, Paavo Järvi.
That this set is seriously lacking in sound quality is a fact for me. Also a fact is that despite that, it is artistically a worthwhile addition to your collection, but having said that, I am actively looking for a set that will do more for me as the BIS release from many moons ago. Now I was never a great fan of the fifth Symphony due to the fact that the piano is added as a sort of percussion instrument, and therefore lacks the distinction of either a piano concerto or symphony. The basic material for a good Symphony is there, but this piano ruins everything for me. Under the hands of Pöntinen it sounds more like a machinegun, trying to hit the keys as hard as he can. The first movement is a bombastic piece of hyperbole, and at that musically as insignificant as can be. I can not even listen more as the first movement, so this work is clearly a no go area for me.
The Sixth Symphony brings everything into balance again, and life goes on. A fine work, in the line of all the others, apart from the fifth that is.
The violin concerto has as a soloist Anton Kontra, an experienced musician, who knows his way around classical music, and would be perfectly capable of delivering a stunning performance, but in fact it is a let down, not only Kontra's contribution but also Järvi's take on the orchestral part. Uninvolving, without meaning, just a bland rendering of a concerto that has so much more to say as on this recording. There is no begeisterung anywhere. For me a complete dud!
Sound is not that good either. So apart from the 6th symphony this disc will have no playing time with me!
I am sorry that I have not more positive words to add.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
My playlist for 25-4-2018.
If by any chance you might be interested in my thoughts or feelings about the recordings of today, please let me know, and I will provide ad...


-
A fine disc. This is my second rerun, and I stick to my first review, which was quite a positive one. First review of this disc. ...
-
From the 206 titles available in the BIS sale, there were not many of interest for me. A lot of new composers, but their modernity was a tad...
-
New acquisition. (2018) First listen: 14-4-2018. Second listen: 20-4-2018. Label: Crystal Classics. Recording dates: November 2008 &...
-
New acquisition. (2016) First listen: 16-4-2018. Label: Hanssler. CD 18 from 20. Recording dates: September 1998. Venue: St. Katharinen...
-
New acquisition. 2016. First listen: 9-4-2018. Label: EMI. CD 5 & 6 from 6. Recording dates: 1971-1986. Venues: Somewhere in Munich...
-
New acquisition. (2017) First listen: 11-4-2018 Label: Dynamic. CD 19 from 29. Recording dates: March 2004. Venue: Sovizzo, Chiesa di ...
-
New acquisition. (2016) First listen: 11-4-2018. Label: Hanssler. CD 16 from 20. Recording dates: January 1999. Venue: Garrison Church,...
-
New acquisition. (2016) First listen: 9-4-2018. Label: Hanssler. CD 14 & 15 from 20. Recording dates: October 1999. Venue: Nidaros ...
-
New acquisition. (2016) First listen: 6-4-2018. Label: Hanssler. CD 11 from 20. Recording dates: March 1999. Venue: Martinikerk in Gron...
-
New acquisition. (2016) First listen: 11-4-2018. Label: Hanssler. CD 17 from 20. Recording dates: March 1997. Venue: Municipal Church o...
